Thursday, November 26, 2015

Thanksgiving: History & Myth (from November 22, 2015, UTR #46): a reflection on Urban Theologian Radio by Jennifer Bell

We have so many rituals, expectations, and illusions surrounding the holidays, don’t we? If we’re not talking turkey, we’re talking the Mayflower. Thanksgiving is actually pretty awesome for this reason, this fascinating aspect of being human: we love that repetition, that tradition, the story. We are storytellers, and we incorporate props into our tales. The props may vary. The construction paper turkeys made from the handprints of our children, the stuffing prepared “just so,” the dining room table itself. (When we violate the dictates of the narrative, the people freak: I’m thinking how my mom still hasn’t gotten over the time I ordered my whole meal from a BBQ joint instead of cooking it myself like a good wife and mother. I’m thinking about how when I lived in Manhattan, I went out for Chinese on Broadway with a friend—and the friend seriously asked our poor waiter, “Are there seconds?”) Our stories, real or imagined, are important to us.

But, really, it’s the psychology of story, the need for story: it’s how we make sense of things. Stories speak to our need for meaning. This is my all-time favorite essay on the human need for story, which ultimately harks back to our Thanksgiving celebrations. Read it. I love it every time I look at it. (I seriously do. Required reading for all writers.)

Thanksgiving is a great time to gather, to give thanks, to load up on cranberry sauce and sweet potatoes; these are good things. But we are really there for the story. Note and note hard: story is intrinsically, significantly, forever bonded with, history. History is story. A true story. We need to revel in, guard it, think on it. When we gather around the table at Thanksgiving, aren’t we ultimately saying, “This is our story”? We are celebrating our story.

This episode of Urban Theologian radio centers on an important, more basic question: What is a Christian view of history? Dr. Robert Tracy McKenzie, author of The First Thanksgiving: The Real Story & What It Can Teach Us and History Department Chair at Wheaton College, was the guest. His blog, which focuses on Christianity and history, sounds great to me. Like something to regularly read . . .

I would encourage you to listen to the show and read more on the topic. In answer to the above question, Dr. McKenzie notes a few principles: God has created us to live as historical beings, we live in historical contexts, God is the Lord of history, history is a kind of revelation, we can draw lessons from the past, and we can see the present more clearly.

The episode moves on to discuss the first Thanksgiving, which is clearly history and story. Suddenly, it’s not all about turkey anymore—not when one is thinking about a Christian perspective. I found some of the details very interesting. How had I missed the part where the pilgrims spent twelve years in Holland before coming to North America?

How, then, should churches be more historically aware? We might understand that we are, by definition, historians! (I would add storytellers.) There’s an “intentional forgetting” of the past that seems to accompany the secularizations of cultures—and the church should actively resist this. Claim history! This is a great episode to get one thinking about our understanding of history, of ritual, of myth. I’d use it as a way launch further study on history, on story, on our need for meaning. While revisionist history is anathema to many of us, our failure to grasp history might be just as bad. This must be part of dominion, right?

Happy Thanksgiving!



No comments: